War literary quiz.

Joined Nov 2007
7,628 Posts | 9+
Alba
Yep, it was Killiecrankie. If you know the poem, can you remember who wrote it?
 
Joined May 2008
14,765 Posts | 384+
Scotland
Sorry Chookie, I couldn't remember and so had to visit the bookcase. Now that I've made another mess, I can say: William Edmonstoune Aytoun, an Edinburgh man I believe (given the name, I'm not surprised I couldn't remember!). :)


Okay, here's another.

'All the same, I am no pessimist. I stick to the view I have always held that Hitler missed the bus in Sept 1938. He could have dealt France and ourselves a terrible, perhaps a mortal, blow then.'
 
Joined Jan 2007
16,359 Posts | 31+
Nebraska
'All the same, I am no pessimist. I stick to the view I have always held that Hitler missed the bus in Sept 1938. He could have dealt France and ourselves a terrible, perhaps a mortal, blow then.'

That would have been Neville Chamberlain, right?
 
Joined Jan 2007
16,359 Posts | 31+
Nebraska
Did you know or was it an obvious guess?

Well, that "missed the bus" thing was thrown in his face for a long time after, right?

And now for something completely different -

"And now," said he, "since it is resolved among you that you will die, come on, let us commit our mutual deaths to determination by lot. He whom the lot falls to first, let him be killed by him that hath the second lot, and thus fortune shall make its progress through us all; nor shall any of us perish by his own right hand, for it would be unfair if, when the rest were gone, somebody should repent and save himself. This proposal appeared to them to be very just;"
 
Joined Nov 2007
7,628 Posts | 9+
Alba
Is this part of the speech attributed to Elazar ben Ya'ir (Commander of the Jews on Masada) by Joshephus?
 
Joined May 2008
14,765 Posts | 384+
Scotland
‘… and when he had prevailed with them to determine this matter by lots, he drew one of the lots for himself also.’

Well done, Chookie!
 
Joined Nov 2007
7,628 Posts | 9+
Alba
Well that's what I get for relying a half-remembered fact which was hiding the darkest corner of my braincell.
 
Joined Jan 2007
16,359 Posts | 31+
Nebraska
Not at all, Chookie. You had the author of the quote right. Go ahead please if you like.
 
Joined Nov 2007
7,628 Posts | 9+
Alba
There are many dead in the brutish desert,

who lie uneasy

in the scrub in this landscape of half-wit

stunted ill-will. For the dead land is insatiate

and necrophilious. The sand is blowing about still.

Many who for various reasons, or because

of mere unanswerable compulsion, came here

and fought among clutching gravestones,

shivered and sweated,

cried out, suffered thirst, were stoically silent, cursed

the spittering machine-guns, were homesick for Europe

and fast embedded in quicksand of Africa

agonised and died.

And sleep now. Sleep here the sleep of the dust.

Author and title please.
 
Joined Apr 2008
2,198 Posts | 3+
Sodom and Begorrah
great poem
we can say one thing for certain that the author will be scottish
 
Joined Mar 2008
17,260 Posts | 97+
On a mountain top in Costa Rica. yeah...I win!!
I would call it lyric prose. I am going to take a wild guess. Is it T.S. Lawrence?
 
Joined Nov 2007
7,628 Posts | 9+
Alba
No Pedro, T. S. Lawrence it most definitely isn't.

Galteeman was correct when he said "the author will be Scottish". Those of us who are so favoured consider it a duty to inform the lesser breeds.
 
Joined May 2008
14,765 Posts | 384+
Scotland
I can't get his name out of my damn mouth - it's been one of those days!!!

The composer was born in Edinburgh (late 18th century??)
 
Joined Nov 2007
7,628 Posts | 9+
Alba
I can't get his name out of my damn mouth - it's been one of those days!!!

The composer was born in Edinburgh (late 18th century??)

Nope.

Excuse me while I indulge in an evil laugh or two..............
 
Joined Mar 2008
17,260 Posts | 97+
On a mountain top in Costa Rica. yeah...I win!!
Machine gun, a clue?...first world war?
 

Trending History Discussions

Top