Why is There So Much Negativity Surrounding Iranian History and Culture?

Joined Jun 2013
6,524 Posts | 140+
USA
Ridiculing and distorting Iranian history and culture is a habit common in different mediums ranging from popular culture in many countries, online forums, the scholarly community, the pseudo-scholarly community, to some forces in Iran itself. The negativity is so striking that I cannot help but wonder about the reason behind it. Do we Iranians simply "suck" at history? Is it because of envy and prejudice? Did we knock out a lot of teeth? I don't really know.

My people have suffered too much, and one would think that outsiders would somehow sympathise with Iranians and appreciate their history and contributions to humanity as much as they do to other peoples in different civilisations. But that's not the case apparently.

This is not a rant and I'm not playing the victim card to draw attention. I have lurked in many online forums and websites and read a considerable number of books and articles that tackle the subject of Iranian history. I have exposed myself to Western popular culture and to different opinions from people of different backgrounds and orientations both online and offline. I don't even live in Iran, so I'm in a position to look at the subject from the perspective of an outsider. With that having been said, I think I'm justified in claiming that the negativity surrounding Iranian history and culture is too obvious not to be noticed, and this negativity is not comparable to anything similar regarding other civilisations that seem to enjoy favourable reputations overall, at least when compared to the Iranian.

So the question is:

Why has the history of Iranian Civilisation been a victim of propaganda, distortion, and wilful ignorance?

Note: If you have an axe to grind, I'll not appreciate your participation in this thread. I've heard and seen too much nonsense not to be able to recognise the foul odour of agenda-promoters. So here's something to consider.

Well, in the USA, the majority of people who are rather ignorant in history view Persia as positive and Iran as negative because of things like the hostage crisis and anti-American rhetoric. Persia is viewed like Greece or Rome as a badass mystical ancient power while Iran is viewed as an annoying hateful nation. Just misperceptions really based on a simple name.
 
Joined Feb 2012
900 Posts | 1+
Iudaea
Iran has some of the richest cultural heritages the world has ever seen.
I've always been in awe of Iran's rich history. I always thought that Iran kept its language and not switched to Arabic was because the language had such a rich tradition and such a prestigious status that it never crossed the people's minds to start speaking Arabic as opposed to Mesopotamia, Levant and North Africa were Arabic and its many local dialects prevailed.

The negativity people have about Iran stems from the Islamic regime installed in 1979. During the times of the secular monarchy Iran was extremely pro-western and went through a significant modernization process. Iran now seems to go backwards with the religious institution ongoing for 30+ years. At least the Islamic regime is modest and not radical as women can drive cars as opposed to Saudi Arabia, as for human rights, Sharia laws are quite controversial but Sunnis, Christians, Jews and Zoroastrians have equal rights to Shia citizens and are protected by the state.
 
Joined Apr 2010
1,682 Posts | 218+
evergreen state, USA
As for me, I never looked into Persian/Iranian history and culture much, although I recognize its rich history going back to ancient times. The Average American these days only hears negative media reports about Iran and its hostility toward the West/USA. Part of that hostility may be against globalization. I had a German national as a wife when I was in the army, mostly stationed in Germany. She had a .... cousin who married an Iranian medical doctor. They lived in Germany, although I never personally met them. I recall receiving a postcard or two from Tehran when they visited Iran.
 
Joined May 2009
1,694 Posts | 290+
I'm American and I don't have a negative view of Iran. It's one of the great cultures of the world with a long and fascinating history. I'd love to visit one day. I'm sure I'm not alone.
 
Joined Mar 2014
8,881 Posts | 30+
Canterbury
Hmm...Have you seen Bulgarian, Albanian, Georgian etc. history, mentioned in popular culture?
I've seen Bulgaria come up sometimes, but nowhere near often enough to be a regular thing. Albania's known only for Skanderbeg, Tito, and being part of the Balkans. Georgia hardly ever comes up. It's a very underrated country.
 
Joined Jan 2014
1,994 Posts | 19+
Regnum Francorum (orientalium) / Germany
Everyone knows Omar Khayam.

Omar who?:zany:

Sorry, I do not know him.

ah, that's him: a brilliant mathematician. Omar Khayyám - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

But I know Abū ʿAlī al-Ḥusayn ibn ʿAbd Allāh ibn Al-Hasan ibn Ali ibn Sīnā, but I usually call him Avicenna.

[ame=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avicenna]Avicenna - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia[/ame]

His books on medicine were used in European universities throughout centuries.
 
Joined Jan 2007
16,359 Posts | 31+
Nebraska
Well aside from recent events, it's usually mentioned as the birthplace of Stalin. That is of course when it's not mistaken for the American state.

My neighbor is from there and he insists upon Saqartvelo. It's the earliest Christian kingdom, you know.
 
Joined Feb 2013
608 Posts | 1+
Last edited:
I don't generally see negativity surrounding Iranian history, just ignorance. If you ask most people what they think about Iranian history, they will simply respond: "...What?" Most awareness of Iran is limited to its recent history and what people read in the news. I think we can all agree that the Iranian people are exactly living during the pinnacle of their country's greatness. Negativity of the country's current state abounds and rightfully so.
 
Joined Feb 2013
608 Posts | 1+
Sorry, I made a typo in my last post:

I don't generally see negativity surrounding Iranian history, just ignorance. If you ask most people what they think about Iranian history, they will simply respond: "...What?" Most awareness of Iran is limited to its recent history and what people read in the news. I think we can all agree that the Iranian people are NOT exactly living during the pinnacle of their country's greatness. Negativity of the country's current state abounds and rightfully so.
 

Trending History Discussions

Top