Women Waiting for their Husbands Return

Joined Sep 2011
24,135 Posts | 8+
------------
It is a well known nightmare scenario for any man that is at war, wondering if his wife is going to get fed up waiting and go off with another man.

What about in history? I know this will differ for different time periods and different wars, depending on how far away the battle field was and how long the soldier was away from home. But still, what did women in history do when they got fed up? I know it is something hard to prove but I am curious to your thoughts on this...

Would women have affairs? Would some of them turn to other women, if the male population was very low? Are there any recorded events in history where it was known that women left their husbands for another man or woman? How long did women have to wait before it was acceptable to move onto another man? The tale of Odysseus comes to mind for with this thought...

I know we all have different time era's and cultures which we learn about, so I think it will be interesting to read the response to this thread from the widest variety of time eras. Thanks. :)
 
Joined Aug 2010
6,752 Posts | 17+
The Far East
SovietPictures121.jpg

a painting by V. Kostecky titled 'Coming Home' which shows a russian soldier returng to his family after the war
1_display.jpg

V. Igoshev. Still waiting for her son

Wait for me by Konstantin Simonov was a poam written for his wife in 1941 that went on to be widley popular in the war.

Wait for me and I’ll return, only wait very hard.
Wait when you are filled with sorrow as you watch the yellow rain.
Wait when the wind sweeps the snowdrifts.
Wait in the sweltering heat.
Wait when others have stopped waiting, forgetting their yesterdays.
Wait even when from afar no letters come for you.
Wait even when others are tired of waiting.

Wait for me and I’ll return, but wait patiently.
Wait even when you are told that you should forget.
Wait even when my mother and son think I am no more.
And when friends sit around the fire drinking to my memory
Wait and do not hurry to drink to my memory too.

Wait for me and I’ll return, defying every death.
And let those who do not wait say that I was lucky.
They will never understand that in the midst of death
You with your waiting saved me.
Only you and I will know how I survived:
It was because you waited as no one else did.

ironicly Simonov's wife does not appear to have waited for him and in fact had an affair which was widley known.
 
Joined Aug 2010
2,950 Posts | 1+
USA
"ironicly Simonov's wife does not appear to have waited for him and in fact had an affair which was widley known."

OMG, such a heartfelt poem. And how sad to know the woman it was written for did not wait.


Contemporary, but this gets me everytime. Many of us have soldiers away from home just now.

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2B4E2-FEO8M"]SUSAN BOYLE - RETURN - YouTube[/ame]
 

A7X

Joined May 2010
3,399 Posts | 1+
Orion arm of the milky way
Obviously if she can't want for him to return home and has to go off with some other guy she's worthless and he should consider himself luckily that he didn't end up marrying someone with fake colors.

It makes me so angry.
 
Joined Sep 2011
24,135 Posts | 8+
------------
SovietPictures121.jpg

a painting by V. Kostecky titled 'Coming Home' which shows a russian soldier returng to his family after the war
1_display.jpg

V. Igoshev. Still waiting for her son

Wait for me by Konstantin Simonov was a poam written for his wife in 1941 that went on to be widley popular in the war.

Wait for me and I’ll return, only wait very hard.
Wait when you are filled with sorrow as you watch the yellow rain.
Wait when the wind sweeps the snowdrifts.
Wait in the sweltering heat.
Wait when others have stopped waiting, forgetting their yesterdays.
Wait even when from afar no letters come for you.
Wait even when others are tired of waiting.

Wait for me and I’ll return, but wait patiently.
Wait even when you are told that you should forget.
Wait even when my mother and son think I am no more.
And when friends sit around the fire drinking to my memory
Wait and do not hurry to drink to my memory too.

Wait for me and I’ll return, defying every death.
And let those who do not wait say that I was lucky.
They will never understand that in the midst of death
You with your waiting saved me.
Only you and I will know how I survived:
It was because you waited as no one else did.

ironicly Simonov's wife does not appear to have waited for him and in fact had an affair which was widley known.

Lovely paintings and poem, IRISH, thanks. Do you know when she started her 'affair' and how long she waited for him to return?

Obviously if she can't want for him to return home and has to go off with some other guy she's worthless and he should consider himself luckily that he didn't end up marrying someone with fake colors.

It makes me so angry.

How long should a woman had to have to wait before she could move on?
 
Joined Aug 2010
6,752 Posts | 17+
The Far East
Lovely paintings and poem, IRISH, thanks. Do you know when she started her 'affair' and how long she waited for him to return?
from reading through this is appears he chose his love of his country over that of his wife yet still loved her
Konstantin Simonov

this is perhaps shown in another of his poems

Don’t call it off - you must not spoil the evening!
What if for me you feel a special pain?
What if I loved you? What does it mean
That I shall never see your eyes again?
We gathered here as equals - only later
Fate gave you me alone when back I came,
But sitting in this room around this table
Our rights in you were equal and the same.
Later will be the time when you’ll remember.
Later, if need be, will be time for tears,
When, standing in the cold sheet at the window,
You’ll beg for mercy from the lonely years.
But now you must not spoil with tears and sorrow,
By grief for me deny the final right
To those who yet will go to war tomorrow,
And those, like me, who don’t return tonight


i believe a woman should remain fateful to her lover at war but i understand that can't be easy to go so long with no one and sometimes a long time without any letters. some veterans have expressed how they could never find the words to describe there daily lives so they didn't send any or were very basic in the information they sent, just a few lines on that they were in good health and were doing great. i don't remember who it was that gave this report but it was some british commander who when describing how his men were he said that many very low on moral mostly due to unfaithful wives back home who had left them for american troops.
 
Joined Sep 2011
24,135 Posts | 8+
------------

I don't honestly believe there is any excuse for it in modern times, communication is very good with the forces around the globe, you know when they are coming home etc... what your exes did was quite cruel, Okamido.

I am curious to how it was historically, when communication was not very good, and sometimes you would not know if they had died or not.
 
Joined May 2008
4,476 Posts | 49+
Fireland
Sheesh! My cousin's fiance serving in Afghanistan (bomb disposal) broke off their engagement apparently because he didn't want her putting her life in suspension on his account. She didn't take too well to the suggestion that she couldn't 'restrain herself' and wound up in turn accusing him of fishing for excuses to break it off. An almighty row broke out between them. You can't win either way it seems - she burnt off her frustration by hiking Kilimanjaro (for charity) and yet awaits the good man's return despite being given the 'green light' as it were.
 
Joined Sep 2011
24,135 Posts | 8+
------------
Full length of the tour.

If you can't wait then clearly you don't love them.

I don't think you should wait at all if you don't want to, best to end it before hand than put each other through hell. Modern day is far different though, as I said on a previous reply to Okamido.

I am mainly refering to historical times when men have gone to war.
 
Joined Feb 2011
9,998 Posts | 3+
Cumbernauld Scotland
I suppose now a days periods of being apart from each other are much shorter back say in the first World war the time away from your loved ones was a lot longer if they were lucky. It also not unknown for the men to play away from home also. Its only natural.
 
Joined Mar 2011
3,403 Posts | 0+
just sitting here
Last edited:
It is probably this sort of problem of the menfolk going away to fight that seems to have led to the tribe of the amazons , accordng to Jordane in his Getica c.560 giving the history of the Goths , he states the Goth women fought a battle with a neighbouring tribe and won , while their menfolk were away on a campaign against Pharaoh Vesosis ,
Presumably the women were trained to fight in order to retain their fidelity , as neighbouring tribes are likely to have known their menfolk had gone off to war. It seems the women got some confidence from this battle as afterwards , the women formed an army under Marpesa , crossed the river Don , and invaded parts of Asia.While her sister Lampero stayed in Europe guarding the homelands.

Queen Thalestra of the Amazons was reported to have visited Alexander and had a son by him , but when his second in command reported the rumour to Alexander he is said to have laughed and said ' and where was i when this happened '

the Amazons were reported not to allow any men to live in their territory , and only to allow the young men of a neighbouring tribe to come into their lands for ... (presumably with the unmarried women ?) only once per year, the offspring of these liasons were given back to their fathers if they were sons, and trained as warriors if they were daughters ( how much of this is truth ,and how much myth is uncertain)

The Amazons are said to have aided King Priam , against the Greeks , and their Queen at the time Penthesilea , is said to have been slain by Achilles.She was of Thracian birth, and the Thracians were reputed to hold their women in common (ie the women shared husbands with other women, presumably again because men were in short supply , because of those slain in battle )

In aora linda book the Aeromoeder (leader of the tribe above all men )named Adela , who was supposedly 8' tall , killed 4 raiders with her sword in four thrusts , and in mahabharata most of the women in the 2nd caste of Kshatriyas (the noble class) were trained in the art of warfare ,albeit mostly as archers it seems , and some reportedly fought alongside their menfolk. plus boudica and her daughters sound as though if you wanted to retain your integrity/fidelity in ancient times , you were probably going to have to fight to the death for it .
 
Joined Oct 2009
23,286 Posts | 99+
Maryland
It would seem this is where the medieval myth of "chastity belts" comes in to play:lol:

In the Roman army, enlistment (or being snatched up by the draft) was considered paramount to divorce if the recruit was married. This in fact became a law under Augustus and Tiberius, who completed the process of turning the military into a career (and who also professed great concern for the sexual morality of their subjects).
 
Joined Nov 2009
3,901 Posts | 56+
Outer world
I like in the film "Letters from Iwo Jima2 the perspective of a Japanese wife which is given, waiting for her husband, already knowing he will hardly return.
 
Joined Jan 2010
2,974 Posts | 1+
Incline Village near Lake Tahoe
..................................Ruby

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C2ldtuSfm9g&feature=related"]Kenny Rogers - Ruby 1972 - YouTube[/ame]
 
Joined Feb 2011
13,604 Posts | 165+
Perambulating in St James' Park
In the future we should prolly send the ..... instead, they'll win the war in no time. That way all the guys can sit back at home and watch the telly too.
 
Joined May 2008
4,476 Posts | 49+
Fireland
I'm just thinking there's no way the original Penelope (for there had to be one) sat at that loom for twenty years fending off legions of those amorous dogs (the suitors) while Odysseus gallivanted around the Mediterranean.

One thing I do recall is that Homer synthesised pre-existing 'Trojan' tales which had obviously mushroomed out of all proportion with regards to the adventures with Circe, the Cyclopes, Aeolus etc and so to accommodate the expanded repertoire of Odysseus-related material bards had to steadily increase the time which Penelope was said to have waited.

This story, that the Bard's extended Odysseus journey in order to accommodate his son's coming of age doesn't sit right as the Telemachus sub-plot seems all the time subsidiary to the Penelope story. It must have been considered a very satisfactory 'adjustment' in that it set forth unmistakeably the kind of example women should follow - the long suffering Penelope immune to the suitors advances and holding out courageously for her husband's return.

A perfect feel good tale for future wars and a warning of the warrior's wrath should he be cuckolded. Women whose men were lost at sea or 'missing in action' during multiple Greek wars must have had all sorts of prohibitive norms imposed against them re-marrying too early let alone 'doing the dirt' via this oral tradition.

Of course, within a few hundred years it would instead be the dictates of the Church imposing these norms.
 
Joined Jan 2011
7,239 Posts | 5+
Southeast England
Some women didn't wait for their men at home, some went with them. Armies in past centuries were followed by soldiers' wives, and other women. Even upper class women sometimes accompanied their husbands, like Eleanor of Aquitaine for instance who went to the crusades with Louis VII. 'The Spanish Bride' by Georgette Heyer is a novel about a real life young Spanish .... who married a British officer in the Napoleonic wars and accompanied him on campaign. Ladysmith in South Africa was named after her.
 

Trending History Discussions

Top